ENGR202 2017 Q A2Past paperOld spec ENGR2022:125 marks30 min

ENGR202 Summer 2017 Q A2[VALID] official answers

Consider the control system in Figure A2 in which H(s)H(s) is the plant, C(s)C(s) is the control algorithm and F(s)F(s) is a feedback element.

Figure A2: Feedback control system with controller C(s), plant H(s) and feedback element F(s).
Figure A2: Feedback control system with controller C(s), plant H(s) and feedback element F(s).
Formulas you may need
  • Poles: roots of the characteristic equation; stable if all have negative real parts; dominant = closest to the imaginary axis (learn this)
  • Closed loop with feedback element: XV=CH1+CHF\dfrac{X}{V} = \dfrac{C H}{1 + C H F} (learn this)
  • Hurwitz for a0s2+a1s+a2=0a_0 s^2 + a_1 s + a_2 = 0: H2=∣a10a0a2∣H_2 = \begin{vmatrix} a_1 & 0 \\ a_0 & a_2 \end{vmatrix}, need Δ1=a1>0\Delta_1 = a_1 > 0 and Δ2=a1a2>0\Delta_2 = a_1 a_2 > 0 (given in the question)
  • PI controller C(s)=K1+K2sC(s) = K_1 + \dfrac{K_2}{s} (learn this)
  1. (a)
    What are the name of the signals V(s)V(s), U(s)U(s) and X(s)X(s)? Using Figure A2 as an example, explain the difference between open and closed-loop control. Give a practical example of both open and closed-loop control.
    [5]
  2. (b)
    Assume the following Transfer Function for this part of the question: H(s)=2.5(s2+3s+2.26)(s+2)H(s) = \frac{2.5}{(s^2 + 3s + 2.26)(s + 2)} Determine the poles of H(s)H(s) and sketch their position on the ss-plane. What is the stability of H(s)H(s). Identify the dominant poles and sketch the likely form of the time response mode. Note: this part of the question concerns H(s)H(s) only.
    [6]
  3. (c)
    Using either standard algebra or the rules of block diagram manipulation, determine the closed-loop Transfer Function for Figure A2 i.e. the relationship between V(s)V(s) and X(s)X(s). Next, an engineer implements a simple proportional control system based on C(s)=KC(s) = K and F(s)=1F(s) = 1 where KK is a scalar control gain. In this case, show how for large values of KK the error E(s)=V(s)−X(s)E(s) = V(s) - X(s) approaches zero. What are the disadvantages of this control system?
    [6]
  4. (d)
    Still using Figure A2, now assume the following Transfer Functions: H(s)=1s+10C(s)=K1+K2sF(s)=1H(s) = \frac{1}{s + 10} \qquad C(s) = K_1 + \frac{K_2}{s} \qquad F(s) = 1 What is the name of this controller? Using these definitions of H(s)H(s), C(s)C(s) and F(s)F(s), determine the closed-loop characteristic equation and the associated Hurwitz determinant. Use your answer to find the minimum values of K1K_1 and K2K_2 that ensure stability of the closed-loop system. Note: given a0s2+a1s+a2=0a_0 s^2 + a_1 s + a_2 = 0 then H2=∣a10a0a2∣H_2 = \begin{vmatrix} a_1 & 0 \\ a_0 & a_2 \end{vmatrix}
    [8]